Save Money: The Rancho Gordo Instant Pot Experiment

Dear reader, it’s legume Wednesday again. this time with a bit of a twist. I have been trying to learn more about beans in general, and the sheer number of different pulses has been astounding to me. Frankly, I thought they were all about the same, but my former knowledge consisted of a handful of different beans: pintos, black beans, garbanzos, and a few others. These last few months have been a learning curve.

Prior to this adventure, I thought all dried beans were the same. That impression changed when I bought a sack of Amazon Basics beans, and it took me 90 minutes to cook them in a pressure cooker, instead of the stated 45 minutes. I discovered that Amazon sells “old beans”; now I know.

I switched to supermarket beans and went back to an overnight soak, and I have been pretty happy with the results. However, I’m a guy who always wants to learn. If Amazons Basic are lower tier, what is the highest tier? Apparently, that is the Rancho Gordo brand. A brand so exclusive that no store near me sells it. A brand so favored that a pound of pintos sells for $6.50 compared to pretty decent Great Value Pintos that command a paltry $1 price. That is a 650% increase. I could buy six and half pounds of Great Value pintos for the cost of one pound of Rancho Gordo’s. Are they that good? There is only one way to find out, a cooking experiment! Let’s get started.

Here are the beans and some of the other ingredients I’ll be using. I’m freestyling today’s recipe. I have been watching a lot of bean videos, and I’ve noticed a pattern. Plus, I have some stuff in the fridge that I need to get rid of. That’s the way we cook in Kunaland.

I found this Polish sausage in the fridge (when did I buy it?… hmm, who knows). I also defrosted 1/2 pound of bacon. I like to split up bacon, vacuum-seal it, and freeze it so I always have some when I need it. Today seemed like a good day to use some. In a pinch, you could use 3-4 strips of bacon and omit the sausage.

I decided to use these spices. I’ll be cooking1/2 pound of the dry beans, as it is just my wife and me.

I’ll use 1 teaspoon of oregano, onion powder, and garlic powder and 1/2 teaspoon of cumin, coriander, chili powder, smoked paprika. I’ll also use 1 bay leaf and around 1/4 teaspoon of black pepper and salt. The bacon and the Polish sausage are pretty salty already. I also added around 1/2 teaspoon of baking soda. Baking soda supposedly encourages beans to cook faster. If you want to keep things simple you can just use oregano cumin, salt, and pepper. That would be delicious too!

I began to pre-measure ingredients a while back for my post’s photographs, and discovered that it is a more efficient way to cook. If you are just starting out with cooking from scratch, I would suggest doing this. It makes cooking much easier, and you are less likely to make an omission mistake. I’m using 1/2 of a red pepper, and 1/2 of a small onion. I’m also using 4 cloves of chopped garlic. Don’t judge, we love garlic!

I weighed out the beans (1/2 pound) and sorted them. The quality was very good, and I couldn’t find a single bad bean. I washed the beans, and the water ran clear on the second rinse, which is also excellent.

I set my electric pressure cooker to sauté and cooked the bacon until semi-crisp. I then removed the bacon from the pot.

I then sautéd the Polish sausage. The sausage was optional and not necessary for this concoction, but it added something delicious. I removed the Polish sausage after I browned it.

I added the onion and red pepper and cooked them for about 2 minutes. l then I added the spices to bloom. Blooming takes less than a minute. You know that you can move on when you can smell the spices. Don’t wait too long, or you will burn them.

In goes the garlic. You can omit the garlic or reduce it if you don’t like garlic. For us, garlic is life. I’m scraping off the bottom “fond.” This will prevent a burn warning, and the “fond” will also add a lot of flavor. A stiff, flat spatula is the best scraping option.

In goes some chicken broth. You could use water if you don’t have broth. I’m using the boxed stuff today, but I often use Better Than Bouillon. It is a great staple that gives you broth whenever you need it. I’m using 2.5 cups of broth.

In goes the 1/2 pound of sorted and washed Rancho Gordo pinto beans. I deliberately did not soak them. These are supposedly the freshest beans that you can buy, so I should be able to pressure-cook them for 45 minutes and get perfectly creamy results.

Back in the pot goes the bacon and Polish.

I canceled the sauté function, closed the lid, and made sure the pressure regulator was on sealing.

I set the cooker for 45 minutes and let it rest for 20 minutes after the cook time. I carefully released any remaining pressure and made sure the float pin was down before I opened the pressure cooker.

This pressure cooker is another thrift-store find. I got this IP Lux for $9.99! I love playing around with all of these gadgets. I believe this is the original version of the Lux, as there is no version number listed on its backplate.

Here is the disappointing news: After 45 minutes and a 20-minute natural release, the beans were still hard. These are supposedly the highest-quality and freshest beans. What the heck!

I cooked the beans for 30 more minutes. They still weren’t melt-in-your-mouth creamy, but they were done, and by then our usual 6 PM dinner time had become 7 PM.

I added around 1 tablespoon of tomato paste at the end of cooking. I had read that adding acidic foods during cooking can slow the beans from rehydrating.

I also added roughly 1 teaspoon of vinegar. That is supposed to “liven” the beans’ flavor.

Here are the beans served with some rice and some of my homemade bread. I was frustrated, so I also had a glass of wine. The dish was really delicious. I mean, bacon, sausage, a blend of spices? Of course it was yummy.

I thoughtfully tasted some of the beans, and with my limited knowledge, I think that they are a cut above in flavor. Is that cut above enough to justify a 650% increase in cost? Not for a plebeian like me. I bought some more exotic beans from Gordo Rancho, so you will probably be seeing them in future videos, then it is back to store brands.

Here are my brand ratings:

Top Tier

Gordo Rancho: They are better, but the difference isn’t worth the extra cost for me. Your mileage may vary. I didn’t find any bad beans when I sorted them. I might have considered them if they cooked in 45 minutes instead of the 75 minutes they took.

Good Tier

Albertsons Signature brand (sold at our local Jewel-Osco stores): high quality, pretty fresh. Very few bad beans when sorting.

Walmart’s Great Value brand: Similar to Albertsons. Great price for very good quality.

Goya brand: Similar to Albertsons.

Aldi brand: Similar to Albertsons. Great price for very good quality.

Hurst’s Beans: Similar to Albertsons

Fair tier

Amazon’s Basic brand: more bad beans, older beans. However, with enough cooking time, they were fine.

Menards Dakota beans: Menards is a regional hardware store with a small grocery section. Believe it or not, they sell bags of dried beans. I had to do a lot of sorting because many of the beans were shriveled or broken. However, the end result was still OK.

Dollar Tree Beans: I bought these a long time ago, so my memory is so, so. But they were similar to the others in this grouping.


The bottom line is that the Rancho Gordo beans are better, but for me, a home cook, the cost doesn’t justify buying them. The Good tier beans are just right for me, and they are cheaper too! When possible I’ll go with the Walmart and Aldi beans, as they are good quality and the best value. Signature, Hurst, and Goya brands have some bean varieties that I can’t get at the discount stores, so I’ll buy those too. With inflation, every penny counts, but sometimes a little variety adds a little fun to dinner time.

Peace

Mike